Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image Image

Social Media Marketing for Business

David A. George


October 11, 2013

Why Facebook News Feed Contests Are Worthless (By Themselves)

October 11, 2013 | By | 5 Comments">5 Comments

Facebook recently announced a change in their news feed algorithm. One of the biggest parts of this change is the filtering of “high quality” versus “low quality” content. Without being too explicit, Facebook has strongly suggested that “low quality” content consists of asking for comments, Likes, and shares.

Also, if you remember back to a couple weeks ago, Facebook has completely changed up their requirements for running contests. Now, instead of being restricted to third party apps, you have the option to run contests straight from your news feed – for free*.

Since this change, you can require Facebook metrics – Likes, messages, and comments (NOT shares) – as forms of entry into your contest. Some of this is probably due to the fact that tons and tons of pages were already doing this and it’s hard for Facebook to police, but there’s probably a little more to why Facebook did this…

I mean, why would Facebook make this change to their news feed filter, then turn around and “legalize” news feed contests? If running an effective contest involves using Facebook metrics and a strong CTA, it seems pretty fair to say that your typical contest on Facebook will look like, “Click Like to win a free cupcake!” “What does ‘wi-fi’ stand for? Comment below for your chance to win a free router!” “Post a pic below of your favorite vacation spot and you could win a free trip there!”

So I’m allowed to make statuses like the above, asking for Likes and comments … but they probably won’t get shown in my fans’ news feeds. Uh, my head hurts…

This reasoning from Facebook is why running a highly successful contest from your news feed also requires creating an ad that drives traffic to it. *Not really that “free”, huh?

What to do about it

Well for starters, you could run a Facebook ad. Keep it short and sweet with an engaging picture. If you don’t get good results from that, here’s why your Facebook ads absolutely stink.

You also have the option of using third parties. Now, I know what you’re saying – Why would I use an extra service that’s probably not free to do something I can do for free? I totally understand, just hear me out…

With news feed contests, you really aren’t getting anything in return for your prize, giveaway, discount, whatever, except for some nice news feed engagement and a little extra exposure. There’s no data collected, re-marketing opportunities, or opt-in forms to be filled out. You basically just have the opportunity to engage your fans and get more Likes. And at the end of the day, Likes don’t necessarily pay the bills.

Just remember, it all comes down to what you are looking for…

If you want a totally free, no-extra-software option, run a news feed contest. Still want to run a news feed contest, just with a little more assurance that your fans will see it? Run a Facebook ad alongside. Want to collect more info on your fans and market to them later? A custom Facebook app is your best bet.

Your Turn

Are you going to change up your strategy for running contests on Facebook? Share with me in the comments below, or tweet at me.



David A. George I'm a UX + Growth Marketer passionate about people, music, intelligent UX, Android, and breathing underwater. I'd love to connect with you on LinkedIn, Twitter, and on my website.

  • thackerpj

    I’ve always had such a hard time using 3rd party apps. If I understand them right, it just goes on my page as a tab right? My fans don’t see that because they’re used to seeing me post from my timeline into their news feed. What’s the best way, and or, am I misunderstanding?

    • David A. George

      @thackerpj:disqus – yes, that is exactly where they are located. And you are on to something by saying your fans don’t see them … on their own. Tabs are a great way to put custom content into the Facebook space, then you make a status update linking your fans to the tab. The level of trust is much higher since you are not directing people outside of FB, AND if you run ads to it, FB gives you a discount on PPC rates for keeping inside the FB environment. Does this help?

  • David A. George

    Yeahhhh Mike – bring it! You’re right – most folks don’t think about the quality of the Likes they get. They are just excited when they see that Like count +1. The Power Editor is where the magic happens baby!

  • Pingback: The Facebook Conversion Formula: A Blueprint for Turning Fans into Customers | The Heyo BlogThe Heyo Blog()

  • Pingback: The Facebook Conversion Formula: A Blueprint for Turning Fans into Customers | Nikki Woods: Global Visibility Expert()